
Dear Anna and Ellie:
I hope that both of you can help me. I am four months pregnant with me and my husband’s first child (sex has not been determined yet). Both of my In-Laws are fabulous; the only problem is my Father-in-Law’s controlling girlfriend, whom he has been dating for 13 years.
His girlfriend did not have a very nurturing childhood and she was married and pregnant by the age of 17. It is my belief that motherhood has been the only validating experience of her life, and she believes (or at least acts as if) she is the authority of raising children. She has been overbearing and borderline obsessed with my husband’s biological niece (my niece by marriage) because she never had a girl of her own (she has 3 sons). I’ve seen her control, belittle and speak very lowly about my niece’s mother. Mind you, she is not even related to my niece, but she thinks that she is the only one who can properly take care of her. She’s so psychotic that she thinks that she and my niece look alike, knowing full well that she is not related to her!
Fast forward to my pregnancy, and she is making passive-aggressive comments (which is not new for her) but now I am getting seriously angry and weary of her being around our child when s/he arrives. She is already trying to control the naming process and thinks that we should move closer to them so that we will have a babysitter. I’ve already told her that we are not planning on going out that much and will probably not need babysitters very often, but it’s as if she doesn’t even hear me. My husband has been trying to reassure me that we will not have to go through what his brother-in-law and his girlfriend are experiencing because we will not give them that kind of control, but I am still very anxious. Should I take it up with my Father-in-Law, who probably won’t stand up to her, or should there be a meeting with her and my Father-in-Law to explain what their boundaries are as the “grandparent” figures? I really need help!
–Pregnant Twenty-Something
Dear Pregnant Twenty-Something:
Congratulations on your pregnancy! We are very happy for you and your husband, and we wish you many years of joy with your new child.
We commend you for taking responsibility for your child already, which is indeed what you are doing by seeking solutions to your dilemma before your child is born. Please know that both of us have direct personal experience with the issues you face, from both the mother’s perspective and the child’s: Anna would like you to know that you are much stronger and wiser than she was as a new parent. Ellie would like to tell you how much easier her life would have been if Anna had addressed these same types of concerns before she and her siblings were born, and that you can’t shield children from family dynamics no matter how hard you try. We are very proud of you.
You are quite perceptive in your understanding of your father-in-law’s girlfriend! Your insight into her life, along with how her past is influencing her present behavior, will be helpful as you reason through your situation.
Let’s start at the beginning: According to Magna Sententia, you and your husband are responsible for your child’s life. This does not mean that you shouldn’t consider the advice or guidance others give you; however, it does mean that outside input (from anyone besides you and your husband) only matters if you let it matter. Whether your father-in-law’s girlfriend is well-intentioned or otherwise, do not permit her to “control, belittle, and speak very lowly” about you as a mother or your husband as a father.
Now, this may sound harsh, but it is the truth: It doesn’t matter if she had a terrible childhood, was young and pregnant when she married, and never had a daughter of her own. Her behavior is completely inappropriate, and you and your husband will only make your lives, and the life of your child, more difficult if you allow her to control you, influence your parenting, or just be an annoyance in your lives. (It takes up a great deal of energy to contend with relatives who make you feel badly.) Life is simply too busy and difficult on its own without these problems, and much too short to let people like your father-in-law’s girlfriend assume a prominent role.
We teach others how to treat us: She will continue to get away with being passive-aggressive only until you no longer allow her to be passive-aggressive. She will control the naming process only until you take control of the naming process. (Name your child exactly what you and your husband want to name him or her.) Knowing what we know now (and wish we would have known three decades ago), it is in your family’s best interest to stop her behavior immediately, even if this means it gets ugly for a while (or forever) with her or your extended family.
How?
First of all, do not try to go through your father-in-law because, as you said, he will probably not stand up to his girlfriend. You and your husband, together, need to stop this directly at the source, (although your husband should really be the one to take the lead because it is his family). As a courtesy, your husband may want to tell his father that the two of you are going to ask to meet with her and that he is welcome to attend if he would like. Then, your husband should set up a meeting with the three (or four) of you where you can communicate for as long as you need without any distractions. (In Magna Sententia, this process is called Rectify, and it is discussed thoroughly with examples in the book.)
At the meeting, you and your husband can start by explaining how important your family is to you. Next, tell her what you told us: “We have seen you control, belittle, and speak very lowly about our niece’s mother, and we are worried because you are already starting to be overbearing and passive-aggressive with us: For instance, you are trying to control the naming process, as well as persuade us to move closer to you.
“In addition, even though you may have good intentions and not realize it, you give off the impression that you are an authority in raising children and that you have all the answers. While we are, at times, open to suggestions regarding our child, we do not want you to try to take over. If you do, you will not be included in our child’s life. We are not trying to be mean; we just want you to know from the beginning that you cannot do to us what you have done to our niece’s mother. We have every right to be concerned because you have already started with us, and you must stop this immediately.”
Even if you ruffle her feathers for a month, a year, or she never speaks to you again, you will be saving yourselves years of grief by standing firm. Hear us when we say that there is nothing worse than a relative like your father-in-law’s girlfriend. For the good of your family, it has to be that she either changes her tune, or she is out. (Note: with people, if you give an ultimatum, you have to follow through; otherwise, they will never take you seriously again.)
The reason for this strict stance is that if you do not set the ground rules now, she eventually will control, belittle, and speak very lowly of you. And your child (and future children) will know. You may try to cover up what is going on and how you feel, but children are extremely perceptive, and they will know. (Ellie and her siblings all knew.) You will have holidays, birthday parties, and family gatherings ruined, along with a great chance of strife between you, your husband, and/or your father-in-law, and all for what? A woman who is selfish and controlling?
We hope that your troubles are settled relatively peacefully, but you and your husband also have to prepare for the worst. The fact is that your husband has to be united with you in order for there to be harmony in your family, and it is crucial that when push comes to shove, your husband chooses you (and your family with him) over his relationship with his father. This may be extremely difficult for him, but he has to recognize that his responsibility is to you and your family. His allegiances must lie with you, or it will negatively affect your marriage. As your child’s father, he needs to understand that it is unhealthy to have such an out of control relative as part of his child’s life and that it is up to the two of you to control the situation. Also, if the worst possible scenario does come true and your husband becomes estranged from his father over this, your husband must realize that his father has in effect chosen his (manipulative) girlfriend over him.
Please let us know how everything turns out.
–Anna & Ellie
Do you have a life or relationship question for Anna and Ellie? Do you want to know how Magna Sententia applies to your situation? Submit your question here!
Disclaimer
Anna Sherise and Ellie Sherise are not licensed or trained healthcare professionals, counselors, or financial advisors. “Ask Anna & Ellie” is provided for informational purposes only, and is not intended to take the place of the care and advice given to you by your physician, counselor, other healthcare professional, or financial advisor. Sherise Media LLC, its members and representatives, specifically disclaim all responsibility for any liability, loss, or risk, personal or otherwise, which is incurred as a consequence, directly or indirectly, of the use and application of any of the contents of this article and/or website.